Wednesday, June 27, 2007
Saturday, June 23, 2007
Wednesday, June 13, 2007
Hegel Resources
(In-progress)
1. Line by line commentary of "Lordship and Bondage," brought to you by Marxists.org (composed by J. N. Findlay, and appeas in Miller's translation of Phenomenology of Spirit).
2. Commentary for all of the Phenomenology of Spirit.
1. Line by line commentary of "Lordship and Bondage," brought to you by Marxists.org (composed by J. N. Findlay, and appeas in Miller's translation of Phenomenology of Spirit).
2. Commentary for all of the Phenomenology of Spirit.
Tuesday, June 12, 2007
Current Caucus Contents
The following texts are currently available on the Caucus in PDF format (available to SFU students only, all files distributed in strict accordance with Canadian copyright laws for distribution of educational materials):
1 Selections from The Heidegger Controversy
2 Nietzsche, The Birth of Tragedy––Complete Text in PDF Format
3 Lyotard, "What is Postmodernism?"
4 DuBois Selection
5 Nietzsche's "The DIonysian Worldview"
6 Kafka's "Before the Law"
7 From Deleuze's book on Kant
8 Kafka's "In the Penal Colony"
1 Selections from The Heidegger Controversy
2 Nietzsche, The Birth of Tragedy––Complete Text in PDF Format
3 Lyotard, "What is Postmodernism?"
4 DuBois Selection
5 Nietzsche's "The DIonysian Worldview"
6 Kafka's "Before the Law"
7 From Deleuze's book on Kant
8 Kafka's "In the Penal Colony"
Saturday, June 9, 2007
Wednesday, June 6, 2007
Reading Kant
1. Kant's Epistemological Framework: Basic Vocabulary and Concepts
Kant on the à priori and the à posteriori (selected excerpts from the "Introduction" the Critique of Pure Reason):
Kant on the à priori and the à posteriori (selected excerpts from the "Introduction" the Critique of Pure Reason):
- "That all our knowledge begins with experience there can be no doubt. For how is it possible that the faculty of cognition should be awakened into exercise otherwise than by means of objects which affect our senses, and partly of themselves produce representations, partly rouse our powers of understanding into activity, to compare, to connect, or to separate these, and so to convert the raw material of our sensuous impressions into a knowledge of objects, which is called experience? In respect of time, therefore, no knowledge of ours is antecedent to experience, but begins with it." (1)
- "Thus, if a man undermined his house, we say, 'he might know à priori that it would have fallen'; that is, he needed not to have waited for the experience that it did actually fall. But still, à priori, he could not know even this much. For, that bodies are heavy, and, consequently, that they fall when their supports are taken away, much have been known to him previously by means of experience" (2)
- "By the term 'knowledge à priori,' therefore, we shall in the sequel understand, not such as is independent of this or that kind of experience, but such as is absolutely so of all experience. Opposed to this is empirical knowledge, or that which is possible only à posteriori, that is, through experience. Knowledge à priori is either pure or impure. Pure knowledge à priori is that with which no empirical element is mixed up. For example, the proposition, "Every change has a cause," is a proposition à priori, but impure, because change is a conception which can only be derived from experience." (2)
Tuesday, June 5, 2007
Caucus Active!
Supplementary and recommended readings are available on the Caucus (available to SFU students with valid ID only).
This week's feature: "Answering the Question: What is Postmodernism?" (Optional reading).
This week's feature: "Answering the Question: What is Postmodernism?" (Optional reading).
Saturday, June 2, 2007
Notice of Extension
The new due date for the second critical response is June 20th. Please note that all of the other due dates remain the same. I encourage you to submit your second critical response before the new due date, as it will make it easier for me to return it to you before I distribute the midterm examination.
Thursday, May 31, 2007
Kant Resources
1. Kant Dictionary.
As you have probably noticed, many of Kant's terms, such as "idea," "interest," and "beauty," differ from conventional usage (in both English and German). I thought that perhaps a brief glossary of Kant's terms might be helpful. The best one I could find was on the web:
Glossary of Kant's Technical Terms
Immanuel Kant Biographical Sketch (PDF)
2. Gilles Deleuze on Kant
The critical response to Kant is vast in all respects. For a quick overview/brush-up, I find the Penguin Dictionary of Philosophy's entry on Kant very helpful. There is also a Kant for Beginners, although I have not personally examined it. However, a personal favourite of mine is Gilles Deleuze's little book entitled Kant's Critical Philosophy. Deleuze, who is most famous for his contribution to the rather wild and "trippy" A Thousand Plateaux, an enormous critical work co-authored with Félix Guattari, may seem like the last person who would want to write a book on Kant (many people do not even know that Guattari and Deleuze are separate people). However, it is extremely accessible and short (less than 80 pages, in fact). Deleuze devotes a brief section to each of Kant's three critiques, and relies upon close readings of selected passages. I have requested that this title be placed on reserve. Deleuze also authored a book on Nietzsche, which I recommend as well.
3. Websites
a. "Kant's Aesthetics and Teleology" from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
As you have probably noticed, many of Kant's terms, such as "idea," "interest," and "beauty," differ from conventional usage (in both English and German). I thought that perhaps a brief glossary of Kant's terms might be helpful. The best one I could find was on the web:
Glossary of Kant's Technical Terms
Immanuel Kant Biographical Sketch (PDF)
2. Gilles Deleuze on Kant
The critical response to Kant is vast in all respects. For a quick overview/brush-up, I find the Penguin Dictionary of Philosophy's entry on Kant very helpful. There is also a Kant for Beginners, although I have not personally examined it. However, a personal favourite of mine is Gilles Deleuze's little book entitled Kant's Critical Philosophy. Deleuze, who is most famous for his contribution to the rather wild and "trippy" A Thousand Plateaux, an enormous critical work co-authored with Félix Guattari, may seem like the last person who would want to write a book on Kant (many people do not even know that Guattari and Deleuze are separate people). However, it is extremely accessible and short (less than 80 pages, in fact). Deleuze devotes a brief section to each of Kant's three critiques, and relies upon close readings of selected passages. I have requested that this title be placed on reserve. Deleuze also authored a book on Nietzsche, which I recommend as well.
3. Websites
a. "Kant's Aesthetics and Teleology" from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Heidegger's "Patmos"
One of Martin Heidegger's favourite poems, and the inspiration for his famous essay, "The Question Concerning Technology," is entitled "Patmos." The following line stands at the centre of his argument about the essence of technê––"technology":
But where there is danger,
A rescuing [saving] element grows as well.
Read this poem before next Tuesday for some insight into Heidegger's literary roots. It's a great poem and––at least in my opinion––helpful in understanding Heidegger and his style of phenomenology.
But where there is danger,
A rescuing [saving] element grows as well.
Read this poem before next Tuesday for some insight into Heidegger's literary roots. It's a great poem and––at least in my opinion––helpful in understanding Heidegger and his style of phenomenology.
Wednesday, May 30, 2007
Heidegger Resources
(in-progress)
Comics (on the way)
Books
Richard Wolin, ed. The Heidegger Controversy. An absurd omission from our library––but recently made available again by the publisher––this book is this fine anthology of essays by and about Heidegger. The focus of this volume is Heidegger's involvement with the Nazi Party. It contains some truly juicy texts, including Heidegger's essay "On the Self-Assertion of the German University," written during his brief stint as the rector of the University of Freiburg (this should allay any doubt that Heidegger had high hopes for what the National Socialist Party could achieve for the German people in the early 1930s), and his famous interview with Der Spiegel magazine, in which he declares of humanity's fate: "Only a God Can Save Us." Commentary and interviews include scholarly essays by the philosophers Jaspers and Marcuse. In addition, the editor included a brief essay by the radical German author and essayist Ernst Jünger, entitled "Total Mobilization," that inspired Heidegger. The American Amazon.com site includes a table of contents.
This volume is also available at the UBC Library (perpetually checked out) and the Vancouver Public Library (presumed missing in action).
Heidegger, Martin. Nietzsche. Heidegger has published one of the most lengthy studies of Nietzsche to date. This four volume tome presents a rather original interpretation of Nietzsche's works that might inform the reader more about Heidegger than Nietzsche. He focuses on Nietzsche's The Will to Power. Heidegger wrote these volumes during the late 1930s and 1940s, long after the publication of his great work Being and Time. In Being and Time and other early works by Heidegger, the philosopher makes few references to Nietzsche. However, in this book, it becomes clear that Nietzsche played a very important role in the development of his ideas.
Web Sites
Ereignis – Martin Heidegger in English.An extensive catalogue of links to Heidegger resources in English.
Glossary of Terms in Heidegger's Being and Time
Heidegger's Greek Words (unfortunately, the words are indexed in the Greek alphabet)
The Greek Alphabet To help you with the previous website.
Human Beings
Professor Andrew Feenburg. SFU Professor Andrew Feenberg––Canada Research Chair in Philosophy of Technology––has a great personal website with links to fulltext versions of his articles and talks. Professor Feenberg has written extensively on Heidegger, Heidegger reception, and existentialism. He maintains an interest in Heidegger's influence on Japanese philosophers as well.
Comics (on the way)
Books
Richard Wolin, ed. The Heidegger Controversy. An absurd omission from our library––but recently made available again by the publisher––this book is this fine anthology of essays by and about Heidegger. The focus of this volume is Heidegger's involvement with the Nazi Party. It contains some truly juicy texts, including Heidegger's essay "On the Self-Assertion of the German University," written during his brief stint as the rector of the University of Freiburg (this should allay any doubt that Heidegger had high hopes for what the National Socialist Party could achieve for the German people in the early 1930s), and his famous interview with Der Spiegel magazine, in which he declares of humanity's fate: "Only a God Can Save Us." Commentary and interviews include scholarly essays by the philosophers Jaspers and Marcuse. In addition, the editor included a brief essay by the radical German author and essayist Ernst Jünger, entitled "Total Mobilization," that inspired Heidegger. The American Amazon.com site includes a table of contents.
This volume is also available at the UBC Library (perpetually checked out) and the Vancouver Public Library (presumed missing in action).
Heidegger, Martin. Nietzsche. Heidegger has published one of the most lengthy studies of Nietzsche to date. This four volume tome presents a rather original interpretation of Nietzsche's works that might inform the reader more about Heidegger than Nietzsche. He focuses on Nietzsche's The Will to Power. Heidegger wrote these volumes during the late 1930s and 1940s, long after the publication of his great work Being and Time. In Being and Time and other early works by Heidegger, the philosopher makes few references to Nietzsche. However, in this book, it becomes clear that Nietzsche played a very important role in the development of his ideas.
Web Sites
Ereignis – Martin Heidegger in English.An extensive catalogue of links to Heidegger resources in English.
Glossary of Terms in Heidegger's Being and Time
Heidegger's Greek Words (unfortunately, the words are indexed in the Greek alphabet)
The Greek Alphabet To help you with the previous website.
Human Beings
Professor Andrew Feenburg. SFU Professor Andrew Feenberg––Canada Research Chair in Philosophy of Technology––has a great personal website with links to fulltext versions of his articles and talks. Professor Feenberg has written extensively on Heidegger, Heidegger reception, and existentialism. He maintains an interest in Heidegger's influence on Japanese philosophers as well.
Heidegger Slide Presentation (Special Edition)
This slide presentation contains many of the quotes I read in lecture on Wednesday, in addition to a small glossary and other explanations. Please check the new links in the Heidegger Resources post above for new and useful links.
Heidegger Slide Presentation (PDF)
Heidegger Slide Presentation (PDF)
Dif-ference vs. Différance
In his other writings about language, Heidegger introduces the concept of Dif-ference [Unter-Schied; derived from "unterscheiden," "to diffentiate": unter+scheiden = under + "to part," "to dissociate," "to sever," "vaginas"]––"neither distinction nor relation" ("Poetry, Language, Thought"). Sound familiar? (If not, just look at the name of Thursday's reading: "Différence").
Derrida was an avid reader of Heidegger and drew liberally from his ideas. Yet, according to the article cited below, Derrida does not discuss Heidegger's concept of Dif-ference with respect to his popular––and similar––neologism "différance." For a comparison of these two concepts, check out the following article (SFU ID required):
Aczel discusses these concepts within the larger context of writings by Bakhtin, Jauss, Gadamer, and Culler.
Richard Aczel. "Understanding as Over-Hearing: Towards a Dialogics of Voice." New Literary History, Vol. 32, No. 3, 597-617.
Derrida was an avid reader of Heidegger and drew liberally from his ideas. Yet, according to the article cited below, Derrida does not discuss Heidegger's concept of Dif-ference with respect to his popular––and similar––neologism "différance." For a comparison of these two concepts, check out the following article (SFU ID required):
Aczel discusses these concepts within the larger context of writings by Bakhtin, Jauss, Gadamer, and Culler.
Richard Aczel. "Understanding as Over-Hearing: Towards a Dialogics of Voice." New Literary History, Vol. 32, No. 3, 597-617.
Sunday, May 27, 2007
Handouts and Slides from Week Three
Derrida Comics (from Introducing Derrida – PDF)
Glossary of Terms from Derrida's "Plato's Pharmacy" (PDF)
Dictionary of Terms Pertaining to Postmodernism and Modernism (from Structuralism and Poststructuralism for Beginners PDF)
Derrida and Mallarmé (PDF)
Glossary of Terms from Derrida's "Plato's Pharmacy" (PDF)
Dictionary of Terms Pertaining to Postmodernism and Modernism (from Structuralism and Poststructuralism for Beginners PDF)
Derrida and Mallarmé (PDF)
"A Reader's Guide to Derrida's 'Plato's Pharmacy'" (A webpage I recently came across).
Friday, May 25, 2007
Friday, May 18, 2007
Suspicious of Theory? Go to the Symposium
A debate on the "use and abuse" of theory is starting to brew in the Symposium. If this topic interests you, please check it out. I have also began a bibliography of materials related to this subject. (Part of my intention is to get more people into the debate--as I am pretty ecstatic that people are actually posting on it.)
Thursday, May 17, 2007
Benjamin's "What is Epic Theater?"
If you are interested in the full text of the essay "What is Epic Theater?" by Walter Benjamin, please send me an email, and I will reply with a pdf of the text (five pages).
Brecht
Last night, I decided to introduce the dramatic theories of Brecht, as interpreted by Benjamin, to illustrate some of the many ways that theorists and artists have responded to Aristotle over the years. Below is a link to the complete slide presentation that I showed you a portion of last night.
Brecht/Benjamin Slide Presentation (pdf)
As several of you expressed interest in Brecht as a possible research topic, I thought that I would post a brief annotated bibliography.
Brecht on Theater (already on reserve for you!). This is a selected anthology of Brecht's theoretical writings, interviews, and notes. Of particular interest is Brecht's "major theoretic work," "A Short Organum for the Theater." Some of you might notice the similarity of this title to Sir Francis Bacon's The New Organum, an influential seventeenth century treatise on natural philosophy, that profoundly shaped the course of scientific thinking and research. In addition to this "serious" selection are many short essays, some of them only 2-3 pages long, that position the author with respect to a wide variety of aesthetic theories, artists, and intellectual trends.
Galileo is one of Brecht's later plays. Although it is not as experimental or filled with catchy tunes as many of his other plays, it is probably one of his most well written. The subject of the play is Galileo and his astronomical research and its far-reaching social and epistemological implications. Galileo's proof that the solar system is not only heliocentric, but one of a potentially infinite number orbital systems--solar systems, planets and moons, and comets--symbolizes a breakdown of established relationships. Naturally, this challenges a firmly entrenched cosmology, and the powerful institutions that defend it. However, it also leaves people with a new and daunting freedom. The universe is filled with an infinite number of "centres." Which is the correct centre? Where is god? In this play, however, these problems are related to social problems. The breakdown of a cosmology, and the need to rethink basic questions concerning morality, religion, and values, is applied to questions of class and social organization; perhaps it is time for "the people" to rethink their social status, their relationship to social and political institutions, and consider the implications of this cosmological revolution on their daily lives. The emphasis on rethinking existing social and material relationships is part of the powerful influence of Marx and Marxist thinkers (including Benjamin) on Brecht.
The first time reader of Brecht plays will immediately notice the flagrant historical inaccuracies--inaccuracies in the depiction of historical events, Galileo, and the history of science. However, Brecht concerns himself very little "realism" on all levels of his plays.
(annotated bibliography to be continued)
We will examine a number of texts this term that emphasize the importance of the contributions of Copernicus, Galileo, and the circumnavigation of the globe as symbolic of major shifts in the history of ideas. Often, these texts are not as concerned with the actual "facts" surrounding these contributions, but the implications of the their popular acceptance on worldviews. Example that we will refer to this term are the works of Heidegger (esp. "The Age of the World Picture"), early modern utopic fiction (Bacon, Cavendish, Moore, etc.), and Nietzsche (esp. "The Parable of the Madman," "Truth and Lies," Zarathustra).
Brecht/Benjamin Slide Presentation (pdf)
As several of you expressed interest in Brecht as a possible research topic, I thought that I would post a brief annotated bibliography.
Brecht on Theater (already on reserve for you!). This is a selected anthology of Brecht's theoretical writings, interviews, and notes. Of particular interest is Brecht's "major theoretic work," "A Short Organum for the Theater." Some of you might notice the similarity of this title to Sir Francis Bacon's The New Organum, an influential seventeenth century treatise on natural philosophy, that profoundly shaped the course of scientific thinking and research. In addition to this "serious" selection are many short essays, some of them only 2-3 pages long, that position the author with respect to a wide variety of aesthetic theories, artists, and intellectual trends.
Galileo is one of Brecht's later plays. Although it is not as experimental or filled with catchy tunes as many of his other plays, it is probably one of his most well written. The subject of the play is Galileo and his astronomical research and its far-reaching social and epistemological implications. Galileo's proof that the solar system is not only heliocentric, but one of a potentially infinite number orbital systems--solar systems, planets and moons, and comets--symbolizes a breakdown of established relationships. Naturally, this challenges a firmly entrenched cosmology, and the powerful institutions that defend it. However, it also leaves people with a new and daunting freedom. The universe is filled with an infinite number of "centres." Which is the correct centre? Where is god? In this play, however, these problems are related to social problems. The breakdown of a cosmology, and the need to rethink basic questions concerning morality, religion, and values, is applied to questions of class and social organization; perhaps it is time for "the people" to rethink their social status, their relationship to social and political institutions, and consider the implications of this cosmological revolution on their daily lives. The emphasis on rethinking existing social and material relationships is part of the powerful influence of Marx and Marxist thinkers (including Benjamin) on Brecht.
The first time reader of Brecht plays will immediately notice the flagrant historical inaccuracies--inaccuracies in the depiction of historical events, Galileo, and the history of science. However, Brecht concerns himself very little "realism" on all levels of his plays.
(annotated bibliography to be continued)
We will examine a number of texts this term that emphasize the importance of the contributions of Copernicus, Galileo, and the circumnavigation of the globe as symbolic of major shifts in the history of ideas. Often, these texts are not as concerned with the actual "facts" surrounding these contributions, but the implications of the their popular acceptance on worldviews. Example that we will refer to this term are the works of Heidegger (esp. "The Age of the World Picture"), early modern utopic fiction (Bacon, Cavendish, Moore, etc.), and Nietzsche (esp. "The Parable of the Madman," "Truth and Lies," Zarathustra).
Sunday, May 13, 2007
Terry Eagleton's Literary Theory
If you are looking for a solid introduction to literary theory and criticism, Terry Eagleton's Literary Theory: An Introduction might be just what you are looking for. It is short, easy to digest, and well organized. Chapters with fairly straightforward titles just as "Psychoanalysis" and "Post-Structuralism" can be read in an hour or two--and without either getting a headache or feeling patronized. Although the book is slightly "out-of-date," it has been canonized as a classic. In fact, the first chapter of the book, "The Rise of English," has even made it to the anthologies, including our beloved Norton. This chapter discusses the development of "English" as a legitimate academic English in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
This book is on reserve. I recommend to those who intend to enroll in an English graduate program or wish a more detailed introduction to the many theoretical movements we will explore this term.
This book is on reserve. I recommend to those who intend to enroll in an English graduate program or wish a more detailed introduction to the many theoretical movements we will explore this term.
Handouts from Week One
a. Aristotle Handout (PDF)
b. Nietzsche's "How the Real World Became a Fable" (PDF)
c. Heraclitus Aphorisms (PDF)
b. Nietzsche's "How the Real World Became a Fable" (PDF)
c. Heraclitus Aphorisms (PDF)
Wednesday, February 21, 2007
Welcome to English 364
Greetings––Welcome to English 364, the Summer Edition.
The text that I have selected for this course is The Norton Anthology of Theory and Criticism. It is an extremely comprehensive and well edited anthology that will be useful for as long as you continue to study English and the Liberal Arts. The bookstore is offering a good discount on this expensive text. However, for those of you who like to do your own shopping, please use the following ISBN number to ensure that you purchase the correct textbook: 0393974294.
All supplementary materials will be provided free of charge.
Please feel free to contact me with any questions regarding the course. A common question that perspective students have asked me is: will meeting only once a week affect the pacing and structure of the course? Answer: Yes, it will. The number of readings and and the range of authors we will cover will be a slightly lighter than normal. In addition, the enrolment for the summer will be lower than usual; this will bring a small seminar atmosphere to a course that is usually full.
Reading assignment for the first week. For the first session, please read the following short selections by Plato:
Republic (selections from Book VII and X, pp. 64-80), the excerpt from Phaedrus (81-85), and Ion (pp. 37-48),
Thank you!
Greg Polakoff (gregory_polakoff@sfu.ca)
Summer 2007 Office Hours:
Academic Quad 6084: Mondays 12:00-1, Wednesdays 4:30-6:00, or by appointment.
Updated May 5.
The text that I have selected for this course is The Norton Anthology of Theory and Criticism. It is an extremely comprehensive and well edited anthology that will be useful for as long as you continue to study English and the Liberal Arts. The bookstore is offering a good discount on this expensive text. However, for those of you who like to do your own shopping, please use the following ISBN number to ensure that you purchase the correct textbook: 0393974294.
All supplementary materials will be provided free of charge.
Please feel free to contact me with any questions regarding the course. A common question that perspective students have asked me is: will meeting only once a week affect the pacing and structure of the course? Answer: Yes, it will. The number of readings and and the range of authors we will cover will be a slightly lighter than normal. In addition, the enrolment for the summer will be lower than usual; this will bring a small seminar atmosphere to a course that is usually full.
Reading assignment for the first week. For the first session, please read the following short selections by Plato:
Republic (selections from Book VII and X, pp. 64-80), the excerpt from Phaedrus (81-85), and Ion (pp. 37-48),
Thank you!
Greg Polakoff (gregory_polakoff@sfu.ca)
Summer 2007 Office Hours:
Academic Quad 6084: Mondays 12:00-1, Wednesdays 4:30-6:00, or by appointment.
Updated May 5.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)