Wednesday, June 6, 2007

Reading Kant

1. Kant's Epistemological Framework: Basic Vocabulary and Concepts
Kant on the à priori and the à posteriori (selected excerpts from the "Introduction" the Critique of Pure Reason):
  • "That all our knowledge begins with experience there can be no doubt. For how is it possible that the faculty of cognition should be awakened into exercise otherwise than by means of objects which affect our senses, and partly of themselves produce representations, partly rouse our powers of understanding into activity, to compare, to connect, or to separate these, and so to convert the raw material of our sensuous impressions into a knowledge of objects, which is called experience? In respect of time, therefore, no knowledge of ours is antecedent to experience, but begins with it." (1)
The preceding quote is the first paragraph of the introduction. Despite Kant's focus on the importance of à priori knowledge, and his legalistic rhetoric, it is important to note that Kant begins his first critique with a very modern supposition: knowledge begins with experience. However, Kant is careful to point out, human "experience" is not necessarily the result of empirical knowledge and personal, subjective experience. À priori knowledge is not same as the knowledge represented by Platonic "forms"; although "we do not derive this knowledge immediately from experience [...] we have itself borrowed from experience" (2). Thus, for Kant, à priori knowledge is predicated upon the limitations of our faculties of reason, understanding, and cognition. Human à priori knowledge is just that: human. It is based upon our shared experiences, knowledge, and "common sense":
  • "Thus, if a man undermined his house, we say, 'he might know à priori that it would have fallen'; that is, he needed not to have waited for the experience that it did actually fall. But still, à priori, he could not know even this much. For, that bodies are heavy, and, consequently, that they fall when their supports are taken away, much have been known to him previously by means of experience" (2)
However, the division of knowledge into categories does not stop with the distinction between à priori and à posteriori knowledge. Kant is also careful to distinguish "pure" [a concept he later associates with "analytical" judgments] and "impure" [a concept he later associates "synthetic" judgments] à priori knowledge. In many respects, this distinction is similar to the different types of aesthetic judgments Kant discusses in the The Critique of Judgment. Like "disinterested" beauty, "pure" à priori knowledge is "not mixed up" with empirical elements. Pure à priori knowledge, like disinterested beauty, relies less upon our passions and actual interaction with the "real" world:
  • "By the term 'knowledge à priori,' therefore, we shall in the sequel understand, not such as is independent of this or that kind of experience, but such as is absolutely so of all experience. Opposed to this is empirical knowledge, or that which is possible only à posteriori, that is, through experience. Knowledge à priori is either pure or impure. Pure knowledge à priori is that with which no empirical element is mixed up. For example, the proposition, "Every change has a cause," is a proposition à priori, but impure, because change is a conception which can only be derived from experience." (2)

No comments: