Thursday, May 17, 2007

Brecht

Last night, I decided to introduce the dramatic theories of Brecht, as interpreted by Benjamin, to illustrate some of the many ways that theorists and artists have responded to Aristotle over the years. Below is a link to the complete slide presentation that I showed you a portion of last night.

Brecht/Benjamin Slide Presentation (pdf)

As several of you expressed interest in Brecht as a possible research topic, I thought that I would post a brief annotated bibliography.

Brecht on Theater (already on reserve for you!). This is a selected anthology of Brecht's theoretical writings, interviews, and notes. Of particular interest is Brecht's "major theoretic work," "A Short Organum for the Theater." Some of you might notice the similarity of this title to Sir Francis Bacon's The New Organum, an influential seventeenth century treatise on natural philosophy, that profoundly shaped the course of scientific thinking and research. In addition to this "serious" selection are many short essays, some of them only 2-3 pages long, that position the author with respect to a wide variety of aesthetic theories, artists, and intellectual trends.

Galileo is one of Brecht's later plays. Although it is not as experimental or filled with catchy tunes as many of his other plays, it is probably one of his most well written. The subject of the play is Galileo and his astronomical research and its far-reaching social and epistemological implications. Galileo's proof that the solar system is not only heliocentric, but one of a potentially infinite number orbital systems--solar systems, planets and moons, and comets--symbolizes a breakdown of established relationships. Naturally, this challenges a firmly entrenched cosmology, and the powerful institutions that defend it. However, it also leaves people with a new and daunting freedom. The universe is filled with an infinite number of "centres." Which is the correct centre? Where is god? In this play, however, these problems are related to social problems. The breakdown of a cosmology, and the need to rethink basic questions concerning morality, religion, and values, is applied to questions of class and social organization; perhaps it is time for "the people" to rethink their social status, their relationship to social and political institutions, and consider the implications of this cosmological revolution on their daily lives. The emphasis on rethinking existing social and material relationships is part of the powerful influence of Marx and Marxist thinkers (including Benjamin) on Brecht.

The first time reader of Brecht plays will immediately notice the flagrant historical inaccuracies--inaccuracies in the depiction of historical events, Galileo, and the history of science. However, Brecht concerns himself very little "realism" on all levels of his plays.

(annotated bibliography to be continued)

We will examine a number of texts this term that emphasize the importance of the contributions of Copernicus, Galileo, and the circumnavigation of the globe as symbolic of major shifts in the history of ideas. Often, these texts are not as concerned with the actual "facts" surrounding these contributions, but the implications of the their popular acceptance on worldviews. Example that we will refer to this term are the works of Heidegger (esp. "The Age of the World Picture"), early modern utopic fiction (Bacon, Cavendish, Moore, etc.), and Nietzsche (esp. "The Parable of the Madman," "Truth and Lies," Zarathustra).

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I read Galileo for another class and what I found quite interesting was Brecht's question on the responsibility of scientists to their discoveries/inventions. It mentions in the appendix of my copy of the play that Brecht changed the play after hearing of the effects of the bomb in Hiroshima. Initially, I think (I don't have the book right in front of me) Brecht left the question open to discussion. After, however, he changed the ending stating that scientists ARE responsible for their discoveries and inventions. This drastically changes the play as when Galileo decants (or is it recants?) his discovery, he is essentially free(d/ing) himself responsibility of it. Hence the end to the play is also more significant as Galileo comes off to the audience as dangerously careless.

My two cents at least. Heh, maybe I should write a paper on this?

Ian Bryce